Cheiron contest

[Alex Martin]

I vote tomorrow. I have many doubt.....

[Feelgoodlies]

Alex Martin : My Life Would Suck Without You - Kelly Clarkson 9/10
I like this song a lot, it literally is good, and as you know nothing new.

*-Sabine* : So What - P!nk 8.5
I love So What, it's a nice track, the only thing I don't like about it is that it's a bit too loud...

Raul_esp : I choose U + ur hand - Pink  9.8
I loooooooove this P!nk+Max type of songs, funny and very catchy!


-Rebecca : Kelis - I Don't Think So  6.5
Mmmm not really, although it's a copy and paste at the beginning but it didn't catch me!

-Unexpected :  Sandy - I Do  10
I love Sandy, and I loooooove this song, very good tune and very Max inspired...

[Alex Martin]

Ok,in this rainy day in milan i vote......






-Alex Martin : My Life Would Suck Without You - Kelly Clarkson

Written By: Max Martin/Lukasz Gottwald/Claude Kelly

Produced By Max Martin/Lukasz Gottwald

GREAT GREAT SONG....but i can't vote for me

*-Sabine* : So What - P!nk

Album: "Funhouse" (2008)
Written by:
Max Martin / Johan "Shellback" Schuster / Alecia Moore
Produced by:
Max Martin @Maratone
Infos:
Recorded by Max Martin @Maratone & Al Clay @House Of Blues

So What is absolutely great,my second fav pink/max song's after Who Knew.
Vote:8


-Raul_esp : I choose U + ur hand - Pink

Written by:
Max Martin / Rami Yacoub / Lukasz Gottwald / Alecia Moore

Produced by:
Max Martin & Lukasz Gottwald

I like This song but too similar to 4ever....
Vote:8


-Feelgoodlies : Megan McCauley - Tap That

Writters:Max Martin / Lukasz Gottwald / Megan McCauley

Another song similar to 4ever.
Vote:6.5


-Rebecca : Kelis - I Don't Think So
Written by Kelis Rogers/Max Martin/Lukasz Gottwald
Produced by Max Martin/Dr Luke

I hated this song for a year probably. I always said"this is the worst max song"but now i'm in love with it.It's crazy but it's true
Vote:7.8

-Unexpected :  Sandy - I Do

Writers & Producers : Writers: T. Cornelssien, A. Eshujis, P. Alderheim, Sandy 

The song is a bad copy of max/luke style not a hit for me and not at the level of the other songs.
Vote:3

[Unexpected]

Alex Martin : My Life Would Suck Without You - Kelly Clarkson
5 I'm really not fussed about this, I'm getting sick of this sound; though the verses is great.


*-Sabine* : So What - P!nk
9 Really nice song, was the perfect lead single.


-Raul_esp : I choose U + ur hand - Pink
8 Another good song, I prefer Who Knew.


-Feelgoodlies : Megan McCauley - Tap That
7.5 This should get 8 as U+Ur Hand, they are the same song actually


-Rebecca : Kelis - I Don't Think So
4 It is a good song, But something weird about this.

-Unexpected :  Sandy - I Do

[Unexpected]

I'm sorry guys for saying what I'm about to say; but it really bit the way I wanted this to be, I reme,ber reading Alex Martin vote for sand (it was 6 or 6.5) but after I have voted and I gave MLWSWY 5 he edited his vote tov 3, this is really childish and not a class way of behaving, I was being total honest about my vote when I gave MLWSWY 5 I really don't like the song as much as you do guys even my friend(feelgood lies) knows this, but if this is the way of you guys playing, I'm sorry to say this would be my last entry for this competition(which is for fun) but appearantly some of you are taking way too seriously.

[Raul_esp]

I'm sorry guys for saying what I'm about to say; but it really bit the way I wanted this to be, I reme,ber reading Alex Martin vote for sand (it was 6 or 6.5) but after I have voted and I gave MLWSWY 5 he edited his vote tov 3, this is really childish and not a class way of behaving, I was being total honest about my vote when I gave MLWSWY 5 I really don't like the song as much as you do guys even my friend(feelgood lies) knows this, but if this is the way of you guys playing, I'm sorry to say this would be my last entry for this competition(which is for fun) but appearantly some of you are taking way too seriously.

mmm , I didnt realize of it , is it  true alex?? if it is true explain it , everybody must vote according their tastes , I hope he hasnt voted for your vote unexpected , anyway I dont want this contest causes problems for the forum , it is only a play for the fun of the members of the forum , I hope alex clears up what has happened .

[Alex Martin]

I changed my opinion on sandy's song. That's all!!! It's not the first time I did it.

I don't understand your words,maybe it's your practice do this things ang give low votes intentionally  but not mine.

This is my last participation at this contest cos' i'm childish

Honestly You did a poor figure with your comment.

[Feelgoodlies]

Alex, why did you change your opinion?, you clearly did so because "Unexpected" ranked Kelly's song 6, well, we know exactly that he isn't into that song, he always says that, like I remember Sabine doesn't like "Circus" and Vanessa Hudgens songs, and Ahmed doesn't like IKAG, or Rebecca hates "Baby Boy" from Beyonce.

I remember you liked the song once it's posted by "Unexpected" you wrote:

Well really good song and guitar tipical max/luke style

, and I don't think a "GOOD SONG", as you described it, deserves a rank of "3", normally bad or weak songs deserve this rank, so I guess you did it to get back at Unexpected!

Can I say that it's just a game, and there are songs better than Max's, I hope you don't take that seriously Unexpected, it's a game, and we love "I Do" regardless of the votes, and I guess everybody likes his/her entry regardless of the voting.

Cheer up now 

[Rebecca]

oh no, this is not good!
we shouldn't be taking this too seriously, let's remember we are voting on the songs not on the forum members. this competition is fun, I love reading others comments on each song and there's sometimes surprising results.

[Alex Martin]

I haven't change my opinion. The song is good but ONLY cos the guitar remind me the max/luke style but the verse and the chorus are not great.

That's all!!!

I changed my opinion also on I don't think so by Kelis. For me was 4 many times considered the worst martin's song ever but actually i love it. The same for If U Seek Amy. Firt time i've heard it for me was a normal song and after a mounth i realized was an amazing production.

Maybe this is a crime for you but not 4 me. Only the stupid never change own opinion

[Alex Martin]

oh no, this is not good!
we shouldn't be taking this too seriously, let's remember we are voting on the songs not on the forum members. this competition is fun, I love reading others comments on each song and there's sometimes surprising results.

Maybe unexpected take this too seriously.

I'm arrived always in last position but i took it easy with much fun differently by unexpected.

Oh reb i changed  also the vote for your song from 7 to 7.8 but unexpected didn't seen it.

[Raul_esp]

guys ,  I repeat  that it is only a game , I dont want the good feeling  of the forum dissapears for this contest , I dont care really who win , the important is the song , you must vote for the song and not for the member , for the nexts rounds I'll  prohibit to edit the results after you put it in the forums for avoid problems .

these are the results after this eventful copy&paste week :



1)-Raul_esp : I choose U + ur hand - Pink : 45.2

Written by:
Max Martin / Rami Yacoub / Lukasz Gottwald / Alecia Moore

Produced by:
Max Martin & Lukasz Gottwald

2)*-Sabine* : So What - P!nk  : 44,4

Album: "Funhouse" (2008)
Written by:
Max Martin / Johan "Shellback" Schuster / Alecia Moore
Produced by:
Max Martin @Maratone
Infos:
Recorded by Max Martin @Maratone & Al Clay @House Of Blues

3)-Alex Martin : My Life Would Suck Without You - Kelly Clarkson : 43.2

Written By: Max Martin/Lukasz Gottwald/Claude Kelly

Produced By Max Martin/Lukasz Gottwald


4)-Feelgoodlies : Megan McCauley - Tap That : 42.7

Writters:Max Martin / Lukasz Gottwald / Megan McCauley




5)-Rebecca : Kelis - I Don't Think So : 38.8
Written by Kelis Rogers/Max Martin/Lukasz Gottwald
Produced by Max Martin/Dr Luke



6)-Unexpected :  Sandy - I Do : 37.5

Writers & Producers : Writers: T. Cornelssien, A. Eshujis, P. Alderheim, Sandy


I'm the winner this week but I appreaciate to unexpected he's chosen a new song unknew for the most of members , althougt he is the last  his song is the most original .

the next week everybody has the possibility again of being first.

I hope  the arguments dissparear of the contest the next round 

[Unexpected]

Hey Alex, I don't take this any seriously, I always pick songs that I like even though I know some people doesn't or even don't know, go back and check my entries you'll find songs like (Let your heart decide by celine dion) which alot of people didn't know, and now Sandy which I knew nobody know(except feelgood lies) because for me it's not about winning and getting high marks, it's about introducing something new to all of you guys, I really appreciate alot of previous entries like rebecca once picked Def leppard, I didn't know the song before and now I really like it, as I told it's about having fun and introducing new things;

I never gave bad marks to songs intentionally, what I write is exactly what I feel about the song, I don't like My life would suck without you((way too repetitve and not original)) that's my opinion, you and the rest love it FAIR ENOUGH, Sabine gave me 6.5p for sandy even though I gave her 9 for so what just because I love the song,((I didn't gave her bad mark just because she didn't like my entry))

I didn't mean to cause all of this drama, but it was something I have to get it out my chest, no hard feeling for you alex or anyone else, I hope the game will continue as it once started with fun;

in the end YAY for the last position for me 

[*Sabine*]

I'm arriving late and I'm a bit surprised of all the polemics.. But all of this happens the right week as the whole copy and paste thing is quite polemical too! 

Well done Raul for choosing U+Ur hand, the song deserves #1! 

[Rebecca]

I'm happy that people speak their opinion here but it's great that it's all sorted out.

Congratulations to Raul for "U + Ur Hand" and also to Unexpected for last position!